Friday, May 5, 2023

Silicade Measuring Spoons - Change in product

 

Measuring Spoons for Making Silicade 5/5/23

In 2014, when the recipe for Silicade was developed, measuring spoons listed as Norpro 3061D Mini Measuring Sets were available online at Dine Company’s Restaurant Store.

                                         


By 2023 Norpro and Dine no longer sell 3061D measuring spoons and Norpro now sells newly designed 3061 oversized measuring spoons. Beware online as some companies, such as “Lily’s TV Items”, claim to sell Norpro 3061D measuring spoons but they ship only the new 3061 oversized measuring spoons.

In 2023 there are a number of similar commercially available measuring spoons, some of which are nearly identical to the 3061D and some of which are not identical in spite of attempts at standardization (see references).  In 2023 a half dozen of these similar commercially available measuring spoons were tested by filling them to level, not heaping, with water on a balance with 1mg resolution.  The measuring spoons sold on Amazon by three companies: Yellrin, Beryler, and Dostien, were found to be nearly identical to 2014 Norpro 3061D measuring spoons (see below table).

Do not buy Norpro 3061 or 3080 or Table Craft H723 measuring spoons as they all have over-sized level smidgens and the Norpro spoons also have non-standard incorrect level dash volumes.

Water Volume in Cubic Centimeters (cc) of Level Dash and Smidgen Measuring Spoons

Vendor / Year Purchased

ASIN (Amazon Number)

Bar Code

Each Engraved with Fraction of tsp

Volume of Level Dash

Volume of Level Smidgen

Norpro 3061D (Dine) / 2014

No Longer Available

---

No

0.50cc

0.16cc

Yellrin (Amazon)   / 2023

B0958CDQS4

X0031NIPLZ

Yes

0.52cc

0.15cc

Beryler (Amazon) / 2023

B091SW8BD5

X002UZ3227

Yes

0.51cc

0.15cc

Dostien MS-5PC (Amazon) / 2023

B0BBKRJXGK

---

Yes

0.51cc

0.15cc

The Following Measuring Spoons are Not Recommended

Norpro 3080  (Amazon) / 2023

B016VDB512

28901 03080 3

No

0.42cc

0.17cc

Norpro 3061 (Amazon) / 2023

B0002IK4PQ

28901 03061 2

No

0.72cc

0.25cc

TableCraft H723 / 2023

Available from Webstaurant

27875 05972 7

No

0.52cc

0.21cc

Note: making Silicade with Norpro 3061 measuring spoons will make it 40% stronger and making Silicade with Norpro 3080 measuring spoons will make it 17% weaker than recommended.

In the Silicade recipe one dash and two smidgens of sodium silicate monohydrate and one dash of sodium bisulfate are dissolved together in a gallon of tap water.  The following table shows the amount of these chemicals per dash and smidgen:

Volume (mg) of Level Dash and Smidgens of Silicade Ingredients

Measuring Spoon Type

Volume of a Level Dash of Sodium Silicate

Volume of a Level Smidgen of Sodium Silicate

Volume of a Level Dash of Sodium Bisulfate

Yellrin

350mg

125mg

830mg

Beryler

350mg

125mg

830mg

Dostien

350mg

125mg

830mg

 

Note: All three of these recommended measuring spoon types have their fraction of a teaspoon (tsp) engraved on the handle. Spoons that do not have this fraction of a tsp engraved on their handles are not recommended.

The Silicade recipe calls for a level dash and two level smidgens totaling 600mg (6.17mM) of sodium silicate monohydrate and a level dash of 830mg (6.01mM) of sodium bisulfate monohydrate added to a gallon of tap water (pH <8.5) resulting in Silicade (pH 4-5). If your tap water’s pH is greater than or equal to 8.5, in order to get the pH to just below 5 may require an added smidgen of sodium bisulfate monohydrate. After filtration through a Brita filter, two smidgens of sodium bicarbonate (i.e., baking soda) are added in order to elevate the pH of Silicade to 6.5 or greater.

References

1)     Pinch, Dash, and Smidgen; Internet Accuracy Project; https://www.accuracyproject.org/pinchdash.html (2009)

2)     Rowlett, Russ; How Many? A Dictionary of Units of Measurement; Univ. North Carolina at Chapel Hill; http://alltootechnical.weebly.com/uploads/4/0/7/5/4075543/dict_units.pdf (December 2003) The following is quoted from this document:

“dash (ds) an informal unit of volume used in food and drink recipes. Originally the dash was usually a liquid measure, small but indefinite in amount, roughly 1/8 teaspoon or a little less. More recently it has been used as both a liquid and dry measure. Kitchen supply stores in the U.S. and other countries have begun selling sets of “minispoons” in which the dash spoon is designed to hold exactly 1/8 teaspoon, which is roughly 0.02 fluid ounce or 0.6 milliliter.” Note that this definition is of a heaping liquid 1/8 teaspoon not a level 1/8 teaspoon that is 0.51cc (0.51 milliliter).  

“smidgen a very small quantity of material. Until recently, no one thought a smidgen was an actual unit of measure, but recently kitchen supply stores in the U.S. and other countries have begun selling sets of “minispoons” in which the smallest spoon, labeled “smidgen,” is designed to hold exactly 1/2 pinch or 1/32 teaspoon, which is roughly 0.005 fluid ounce or 0.15 milliliter. The word is a diminutive of “smutch” or “smudge”; it originally meant a small spot.”

Note” milliliter is equal to cubic centimeter (cc) and 1 gram of water

Links for ordering measuring spoons:

Yellrin  https://www.amazon.com/Measuring-Spoons-Stainless-Liquid-Ingredients/dp/B09J8CDQS4/ref=sr_1_6?crid=210UDC16DVRZE&keywords=Mini%2BMeasuring%2BSpoons%2BSet%2Byellrin&qid=1683303844&s=home-garden&sprefix=mini%2Bmeasuring%2Bspoons%2Bset%2Byellrin%2Cgarden%2C85&sr=1-6&th=1

Beryler https://www.amazon.com/dp/B091SW8BD5?ref=ppx_yo2ov_dt_b_product_details&th=1

Dsotien https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0BBKRJXGK?psc=1&ref=ppx_yo2ov_dt_b_product_details

 

 

2 comments:

  1. Can I cook with Silicade water? Will the heat from boiling, simmering or even braising mess up the balance of some sort, like pH or stability? I have a lot of bone resorption (age 72), and seem to be low on silica. I've seen numbers of 700 mg/day being safe, so 35-70mg (1-2 qts) seems fine. But with teeth issues, I'm thinking I could do with more silica (along with other nutrients I know about). Thank you for your excellent information and help. (Raleigh, NC - USA)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You can not boil Silicade or any silica water as the silica will precipitate out. You can heat Silicade but you can not simmer or boil silica water. You can drink as much silica water as you want. There are areas in the world where the drinking water is rich in silica and people in these areas live longer and have less heart disease, and some forms of cancer and dementia. You only need to drink 3 to 4 cups a day to remove aluminum. Removing aluminum should improve your bone density. If you have Dennis' 1st book Prevent Alzheimer's on page 99 you will find information on Vitamin Mk2-Mk4 for preventing osteoporosis. Relentless Improvement is a source of this supplement. Here is an excerpt. "Vitamin K2-MK-4 Prevents Osteoporosis What is the impact of long-term vitamin K2-MK-4 supplementation on bone health? High serum concentrations of undercarboxylated osteocalcin are known to decrease bone mineral density (BMD) and high serum concentrations of pentosidine have been identified as an increased risk factor for bone fracture in older adults. A group of 48 women 50-60 years of age was divided into two sub-groups. One sub-group took a 1.5 mg K2-MK-4 supplement daily for 12 months and the other sub-group took a placebo. After 12 months the BMD of the forearm was significantly lower in the control sub-group while the K2-MK-4 sub-group had no change. Also there was an observed decrease in both pentosidine and undercarboxylated osteocalcin serum concentration in the K2-MK-4 sub-group359. A pharmacological dose of 45mg/day of vitamin K2-MK-4 has been used in Japan for the treatment of osteoporosis359. Carlson currently distributes gel caps containing 5mg of K2-MK-4 (Menatetrenone). These gel caps are available from online vendors. Vitamin K2-MK-4 Activates Proteins to Prevent MAC Vitamin K is required for activating the carboxylation of Gla proteins (MGP) and Gla rich proteins (GRP) catalyzed by the enzyme gama-carboxylase. When either MGP or GRP proteins are carboxylated, they can complex with calcium in the blood which prevents arterial and aortic calcification and MAC360-362. The MK-4 species of vitamin K2 has the highest efficacy of all K vitamins for preventing MAC. This is possibly because it is the only K2 vitamin that is both water and fat soluble358."

      Delete